Chapter 1: The Stiles Family Legacy

The Stiles family has endured a unique genetic condition known as ectrodactyly for over a century. This rare congenital anomaly results in hands that resemble lobster claws, with the middle fingers either absent or fused to the thumb and pinky.

While many might view this condition as a disadvantage, the Stiles family saw it as an opportunity. In the 1800s, as the family grew and more children were born with this distinctive trait, they created a circus act known as The Lobster Family, which became a staple attraction at carnivals in the early 20th century.

However, one of their sons, Grady Stiles Jr., would bring an entirely different and grim notoriety to the family, evolving into a serial abuser and murderer.

Grady Stiles Jr., later dubbed Lobster Boy, was born in Pittsburgh in 1937. His father was already part of the “freak show” circuit, showcasing his children with ectrodactyly. Stiles Jr.'s condition was particularly severe, impacting both his hands and feet, which left him unable to walk. Throughout much of his life, he depended on a wheelchair, although he developed the remarkable ability to pull himself across the floor using his upper body strength. This physical prowess would later play a significant role in his violent actions.

Raised within the vibrant carnival circuit, Stiles and his family spent their off-seasons in Gibsonton, Florida, alongside other carnival workers. Their financial situation was quite prosperous, earning between $50,000 to $80,000 each season. Unlike many sideshow acts, the Stiles family often avoided harsher treatment beyond the curious gazes of spectators.

As he matured in this colorful environment, it was no surprise that Stiles fell in love with another carnival worker, a teenager named Maria Teresa (or Mary), who had run away to join the circus. Though she was not part of an act, she developed a strong bond with Stiles, and they eventually married, welcoming two children into their family. Just as his father had done, Stiles introduced their children with ectrodactyly into the family business.

As their children grew, especially their daughter Cathy, who did not inherit ectrodactyly and thus became the focus of her father's attention, the Stiles family's narrative took a darker turn.