What is Immune Exhaustion?

Immune exhaustion describes the gradual weakening of T-cells with each encounter with the same stimulus. T-cells play a critical role in the adaptive immune system, targeting abnormal cells such as those infected by viruses or cancer. When faced with the same threat repeatedly, T-cells may become increasingly fatigued.

Exhausted T-cells remain active yet fail to eliminate the underlying threat. This phenomenon is commonly observed in chronic infections, such as human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and hepatitis, where the immune system struggles to combat the persistent threat for an extended period.

Interestingly, T-cell exhaustion may also be a component of ‘disease tolerance,’ where the immune system opts to limit damage from an infection rather than aggressively eliminate it, which can lead to collateral damage. An example of this is the cytokine storm, where an intense immune response can inadvertently harm the host.

Recent studies indicate that T-cell exhaustion can occur in Covid-19 cases. Research has shown that T-cells in Covid-19 patients, especially those with severe symptoms, exhibited a decrease in number and higher levels of PD-1, a marker associated with T-cell exhaustion, compared to T-cells from individuals without Covid.

Concerns About T-cell Exhaustion from Repeated Vaccinations

Since last year, numerous experts have raised concerns about the potential for T-cell exhaustion due to repeated vaccinations with the same or similar vaccines. For instance, journalist Apoorva Mandavilli noted in the New York Times in September 2021, “In younger individuals, officials must weigh the limited benefits of a third dose against the risks of side effects such as blood clots or heart issues.” Immunologist Marrion Pepper, Ph.D., highlighted that “repeatedly stimulating the body’s defenses can also lead to a phenomenon called immune exhaustion.”

Similarly, journalist Jef Akst reported in The Scientist that “with each vaccine dose carrying a small risk of side effects and repeated vaccination increasing the chances of immune exhaustion—where T-cells exhibit a diminished response to chronic antigen exposure—a rise in neutralizing antibodies may not justify booster approval.”

Reinhard Obst, a professor of immunology at Ludwig Maximilian University, commented, “The idea of vaccinating every four months, or even more frequently, is unprecedented. The concept of T-cell exhaustion raises a valid reason for caution.”

Dr. Sarah Fortune, a professor of immunology and infectious disease at Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health, acknowledges that concerns regarding repeated Covid vaccinations potentially inducing T-cell exhaustion have a scientific foundation. However, she emphasizes that this concern has yet to be proven experimentally.

Thus, while T-cell exhaustion is a possibility we should monitor, it should not be viewed as an inevitable outcome, according to Prof. Dr. Fortune.

Reasons for Optimism

T-cell exhaustion is typically observed in scenarios of ongoing exposure to a foreign threat, such as chronic HIV infection or cancer. However, the antigen found in Covid vaccines—the modified spike protein of SARS-CoV-2—does not persist for extended periods. For instance, mRNA vaccines instruct cells to produce spike proteins to prime the immune system, but this process lasts only a week or two before the mRNA is degraded. Consequently, the stimuli from vaccines do not appear to be long enough to trigger T-cell exhaustion.

Moreover, there is no substantial evidence indicating that T-cell exhaustion occurs with other vaccines. Critics may point out studies showing that individuals receiving repeated influenza vaccinations over several years experienced lower vaccine effectiveness compared to those with fewer vaccinations. However, the role of T-cell exhaustion in this context has not been thoroughly investigated. Instead, factors like original antigenic sin or virus evolution may be responsible.

It's important to note that influenza vaccines are administered annually, making T-cell exhaustion unlikely. In contrast, Covid vaccines are administered at a higher frequency—potentially four to five doses within two years (four doses for individuals over 50 and five for those who are immunocompromised). Therefore, careful consideration is necessary when evaluating the necessity of each booster shot, particularly when they are administered in quick succession.

Nonetheless, when weighing the choice between receiving another booster shot or facing an increased risk of contracting Covid, opting for the booster appears to be the more prudent choice. Although T-cell exhaustion has been documented in Covid cases, it has not been associated with vaccination. There is also evidence suggesting that repeated re-infections or Covid itself can lead to both immediate and long-term health complications.

If you have made it this far, thank you for reading. You can subscribe to my Medium email list here. If you're interested in becoming a member for unlimited access to Medium, feel free to use my referral link, which provides me a small commission at no extra cost to you. Additionally, if you feel generous, please consider tipping me below; any support is greatly appreciated as I navigate the challenges of science writing.

Explore the debate surrounding the impact of repeated vaccinations and the role of T-cells in immune response.

Learn about concerns from EU regulators regarding repeated Covid booster shots and their potential effects on the immune system.